Skip to content

Italian restaurants · West district

Best Italian restaurants in West Barrie (2026)

Who are the best-reviewed Italian restaurants on our list for the West district of Barrie?

The top three Italian restaurants on our list for the West district of Barrie are Jilly's Pasta & Fine Food (4.9 from 19 reviews on Google), PizzaCAPO (4.6 from 212 reviews on Google) and Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace (4.6 from 836 reviews on Google). These 5 are the ones in the West district, out of the 26 Italian restaurants on our Barrie list, which comes from Google Maps' top 30 results for "italian restaurants Barrie" and is ordered by Google rating and number of reviews together. Ratings were checked on November 16, 2026. No business pays for its position. How we rank

Ranking at a glance: all 5 Italian restaurants in West on our Barrie list. Google ratings checked November 16, 2026. Ratings are Google's.
#BusinessRatingReviewsArea
1 Jilly's Pasta & Fine Food 4.9 19 Ward 6
2 PizzaCAPO 4.6 212 Ward 5
3 Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace 4.6 836 Ward 5
4 Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta 4.3 729 Ward 6
5 Cocelli Pizza South End 4.3 845 Ward 6

All 5 Italian restaurants in West, ranked

No paid placement: ads are labelled and kept apart from the ranking. How we rank

Not on this list? How listing works