Skip to content

Food & drink

Best Italian restaurants in Barrie (2026)

Who are the best-reviewed Italian restaurants on our Barrie list?

The top three Italian restaurants on our Barrie list are Lucca Tuscan Kitchen (5.0 from 92 reviews on Google), Licious Italian Food and Catering (4.9 from 308 reviews on Google) and Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Barrie (4.8 from 5,300 reviews on Google). The list has 26 Italian restaurants, from Google Maps' top 30 results for "italian restaurants Barrie", ordered by Google rating and number of reviews together. Ratings were checked on November 16, 2026. No business pays for its position. How we rank

Ranking at a glance: all 26 Italian restaurants on our Barrie list. Google ratings checked November 16, 2026. Ratings are Google's.
#BusinessRatingReviewsArea
1 Lucca Tuscan Kitchen 5.0 92 Ward 1
2 Licious Italian Food and Catering 4.9 308 Ward 7
3 Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Barrie 4.8 5,300 Ward 8
4 Michael & Marion's and The Side Door 4.8 1,200 Ward 2
5 Jilly's Pasta & Fine Food 4.9 19 Ward 6
6 One Eyed Jack Restaurant & Bar Barrie 4.7 3,200 Ward 2
7 Il Buco 4.7 1,400 Ward 2
8 Bacio Trattoria 4.7 594 Ward 2
9 LUCA Barrie 4.7 219 Ward 2
10 PizzaCAPO 4.6 212 Ward 5
11 The Crazy Fox Bistro 4.6 595 Ward 2
12 Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace 4.6 836 Ward 5
13 Casano's Italian Restaurant and Catering 4.5 98 Ward 2
14 The North Restaurant 4.5 497 Ward 2
15 B'Spoke Kitchen + Market 4.5 578 Ward 2
16 147 Ristorante & Bar 4.5 901 Ward 2
17 Fuda Italian Bakery 4.5 1,700 Ward 2
18 Boardwalk Restaurant 4.4 198 Ward 8
19 Casa Mia Barrie 4.4 1,400 Ward 2
20 Milestones 4.4 1,800 Ward 8
21 DoughBox Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta 4.3 268 Ward 3
22 Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta 4.3 729 Ward 6
23 Cocelli Pizza South End 4.3 845 Ward 6
24 The Italian Eatery 4.3 1,100 Ward 8
25 The Farmhouse Restaurant 4.3 2,400 Ward 8
26 Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint 4.2 3,400 Ward 2

All 26 Italian restaurants, ranked

No paid placement: ads are labelled and kept apart from the ranking. How we rank

Filter by area

26 Italian restaurants

Not on this list? How listing works

Questions

Which Italian restaurants rank highest on Best of Barrie?
Lucca Tuscan Kitchen ranks first, with 5.0 from 92 reviews on Google. The list is ordered by Google rating and number of reviews together: the more reviews a business has, the more its own rating counts, so a 4.9 from 800 reviews ranks above a 5.0 from 9.
How does Best of Barrie choose and rank Italian restaurants?
We take Google Maps' top 30 results for "italian restaurants Barrie". We leave out businesses outside the Barrie city limits, businesses with no Google rating, businesses with no working website of their own, extra branches of a chain, businesses whose website we could not take a picture of and some others we removed by hand after checking their website. The rest are ordered by Google rating and number of reviews together: the more reviews a business has, the more its own rating counts, so a 4.9 from 800 reviews ranks above a 5.0 from 9. Ratings and review counts are Google's and link to the source listing. Last updated November 18, 2026.
How many Italian restaurants does Best of Barrie list?
26. Google Maps' top 30 results for "italian restaurants Barrie" gave 30 businesses, and we list the 26 that pass our checks: inside Barrie, a Google rating, a working website of their own, and one branch per chain.